Welcome to Edgar’s Restaurant in the Castle
Nestled within the historic Belhurst Castle in Geneva, NY, Edgar's Restaurant offers a unique dining experience with panoramic views of Seneca Lake. Guests relish exquisite, meticulously crafted dishes like perfectly cooked steak and fresh seafood chowder, enhanced by an extensive wine list. The ambiance is rich in antiques and charm, creating an inviting atmosphere for special occasions or leisurely meals. Diners praise the attentive service, which includes detailed wine pairings and insightful culinary recommendations. With a commitment to quality and an unforgettable backdrop, Edgar's is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a memorable culinary journey.
-
4069 W Lake Rd, Geneva, NY 14456, United States Hotline: +1 315-781-0201 ext. 3
Welcome to Edgar’s Restaurant in the Castle, nestled within the enchanting Belhurst Castle, located at 4069 W Lake Rd, Geneva, NY. This culinary gem not only offers a unique dining experience steeped in history but also delivers a remarkable array of dishes that leave an indelible impression on the palate.
Stepping into Edgar’s is akin to crossing a threshold into a bygone era. The restaurant boasts a beautifully decorated space filled with antiques, perfectly complementing its regal ambiance. Customers rave about the stunning views of Seneca Lake, which enhance the already captivating atmosphere. As Elizabeth Coffin eloquently put it, dining in what was once the castle's parlor is a lovely experience, adding a historic touch to every meal.
As for the cuisine, the reviews speak volumes. Diners frequently highlight the perfectly cooked steak and lobster, and the five-course dinner is a true testament to culinary excellence. Prashant Athavale noted the great food and service during his visit, while Justin Tyler described the atmosphere and cocktails as beautiful—though he was so engrossed in enjoying the ambiance that he hardly noticed the wait for his food. The homemade bread is often mentioned as a must-try, providing a delightful start to the meal.
The service at Edgar’s is another standout feature. Many patrons, including Jake Johnson, have praised the impeccable service, where knowledgeable staff like Brandon enhance the dining experience with stellar recommendations. Victoria Smith's anniversary celebration was made even more memorable with personalized attention, including a tour of the castle after her meal.
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a fine dining experience, Edgar’s Restaurant in the Castle promises an unforgettable journey through food and history. With each dish expertly crafted and served with attentiveness, it’s clear why first-time visitors leave with plans to return. Reservations are highly recommended to ensure that you don’t miss out on this one-of-a-kind culinary adventure.
In summary, from the majestic ambiance to the exquisite dishes, Edgar’s Restaurant in the Castle is a must-visit destination for any food lover. Whether it’s the lobster, the unforgettable seafood chowder, or the delightful wine pairings, every element combines to create a dining experience that resonates long after the last bite.
It was such a lovely experience. We had dinner in what was once the original castle's parlor. The food was delicious, and our server was attentive! Steak and lobster were cooked perfectly!
Even off season this place rocks!!!!! Sitting in a restaurant in a castle just got better and better. While staying for a few days in Belhurst Castle my friend and I took full advantage of beautiful Seneca lake whole enjoying a culinary experience at Edgar's. Start to finish it was a wonderful dining experience. The home made bread was heavenly along with delectable appetizers and entrees we had. Weather you are staying at Belhurst or just want a well done dining experience, you cant go wrong with Edgar's!!
This is a beautiful and historic place. I had five course dinner here. Food and service was great.
Magnificent evening on the beautiful grounds with views of the lake. The food was absolutely delicious. You need to plan an evening here by reservation but it is worth it. The decor of the restaurant is filled with antiques reminiscent of another era. The service was excellent and we enjoyed relaxing on the lawn after to enjoy the view.
Yes you're going to spend a lot, totally worth it. I came here for my 40th birthday and the food was great. Beautiful atmosphere, great cocktails, and good service. We did have to wait a bit for our food but we were having such a nice time it didn't matter. Definitely worth a visit.
We had the food and wine pairing at Edgar's for our anniversary dinner. We had a private room next to a fireplace which was perfect. The food and wines were delicious. Service was a little slow but Brandon and Lexi did a phenomenal job explaining the dishes and how they paired with the wines. After our meal Brandon gave us a tour of the castle and showed us small details in the castle architecture and artwork. It was a great night. If we come again we'll definitely ask for Brandon and Lexi again!
Can’t say enough good things about this place. 1) the seafood chowder is easily top 5 chowder I’ve ever had. 2) their service was impeccable. We had Brandon as a server, and the guy made the entire experience amazing. Gave the best recommendations. And made the whole meal a 12/10 with the added service. 3) finally: the delmonico- this may have been the best seasoned/ cooked ribeye I have ever had. If not it’s easily top 3. When we are back in the area, I cannot wait to revisit Edgar’s. 15/10 would recommend
We came here for our first Wedding Anniversary on 10-21-24. Great atmosphere, food & service! Thank you